Tuesday, February 12, 2013

The Effect of a Good Decision Making Policy

Elements of a Business

A business is simply a repeatable process: Creating -> Marketing -> Selling -> Collecting -> Accounting -> Expanding -> Creating -> Marketing -> etc. if it does not repeat the process, it ceases to become a business. The individual activities that compose the business require a set of good decision making for them to support this whole cycle. Failing to act on a specific problem arising from any of the activities creates leaks in the cycle that sooner or later, if not fixed, can become the reason for the business to disappear.

This is the reason why in a business, a greater degree of control must be established and maintained. If for instance you do not have control over the flow of your inventory goods, losses are apparent; and worse is when you only know you lost something once it has already reached to a critical obvious point. The ability to make decisions pertaining to policy improvements equates to greater control and means that the business is highly likely to continue operating. Losing control of any decision making process means putting the trust on whoever has that control and hoping he does not cause the business to fail.

Like a lot of traditional Filipino-Chinese-owned businesses, my grandfather did the same thing with ours. He started the retail store back in the 1960s alone. He hired a few folks to do those menial tasks like carrying cartons, entertaining customers, and few others, but primarily, he was a one-man team. He was the purchaser, the inventory custodian, the marketer, the sales manager, the cashier, and the owner. He controlled everything and had the entirety of opinions when it came to operating the business.

It was manageable then, when the business was just starting out. Back on those days, there were few competitions, so getting bigger wasn't much of a priority than just simply surviving the daily operation. It was like that until my grandpa started getting ill, and started growing older. My dad came in to help, but that wasn't the only thing that changed; he got a share of that control over the decision making process.

The Decision Making Pie

Luckily, by giving up some of the decision making processes, it didn't turn ill fated. Having handled the purchasing and inventory control, the numerous activities my grandpa handled was decreased to a couple of financial tasks like cashiering and customer relationship. With that kind of setup, both of them now focused on fewer more specific tasks and put their trusts on the other for those they did not have direct control over. That sounded like a very easy task, but in reality, was a very difficult thing to realize.

Giving up a part of the control pie digs deep, affecting in fact the very human psychology. Giving up an important task implies that you are acknowledging you cannot do it all. Of course, you really can't do everything given your finite energy and a limited time! But the very gesture of it elevates the person receiving that part of the pie. It doesn't necessarily mean something negative, and in fact can affect the person positively in a way that he asserts himself worthy of trust. Having the son receive such task means that his father trusts him enough to make him responsible of it. Having the father relinquish it means that he starts realizing that his son is no longer a boy and has become a man. And sooner or later, the son becomes the head of the family and the role he has gotten used to will soon come to a switch.

From being a sole proprietor of the business, my grandpa together with my dad and my grandma became partners; although my grandpa still had 100% business interests. Soon, when all of my dad's siblings entered the business, the six of them had six shares in total, divided almost equally among themselves.

In contrary to the usual setup of a Chinese family business, my dad and his brother did not have more shares than the quatro marias. During board meetings, everyone had an equal weight of a vote and winning an argument most of the time required getting the majority vote, and occasionally a unanimous decision for those very important and delicate situations.

Varying Decision Making Processes

Similar to all of our countries, finding the right form of government is essential. But nevertheless, there is no rightest form of government that acts as a silver bullet. Singapore with his non participatory "Parliamentary Representative Democratic Republic" allowed it to go past the wasteland it once was and now becoming a very progressive human-capital resource intensive country of the world. China being the manufacturing and export capital of the world maintains its communistic "Single-Party Socialist Republic" and still growing in power and influence over the whole world. Japan and England still adopt a cousin of a very ancient form of government, "Constitutional Monarchy" but are two great superpowers who once ruled the sea of the east and west respectively and continue to have exponential influence on the world's language and technological advancements. And sadly, the so-called democratic form of government that has become an ideal form in ancient Greece and a red front-line banner of the US may not in actuality be as effective here in the Philippines given that the majority of the citizens is composed of the under-educated and are simply THE targets of mass-media campaigns during elections.

With the family business setup, having a majority-decision ruling may not work at all, dividing the group everytime the idea of the minority is harshly set aside. Unlike in a country, where the number goes to millions of people, and when the bottom line of all arguments is about the equitable distribution of limited resources, the whole family is directly affected by the outcome of the decision making process. In the whole exercise, the aim is value creation more than equitable distribution, and meeting the minds of seven people is a whole lot easier than even just the key representatives of say the senate, where they come from different backgrounds, and hardly have the same goals and motives. In a family, more or less the same vision, mission, and targets are set and the same value system binds them together, making it easier for a single mastermind to rule.

When I entered the company, I was lucky enough to sit immediately on an executive position and be a director of the board. It was both a brag-worthy and a frightening experience noting for one that such positions were achieved not by effort, but by inheritance. On the board, together with both my dad and mom, we gathered and discussed varying issues affecting the businesses and all of those circumstances required our collective decisions. Similar to the previous board, we individually had the same vote weight, in a quorum composed of the three of us, two votes against one would win a decision, and on occasional situations when my siblings were present, it was a majority 50%+1 vote. The only apparent difference with the previous board was that while they were composed of them siblings, we were composed of the whole family. And that meant a whole lot of varying roles to play.

The Mastermind

In a family business, the greatest asset being the relationship established within the group could be the very same stumbling block of the whole business operation. Even Napoleon Hill remarked that a mastermind group built around the family does not immediately become very cohesive, and in fact can be counter productive due to over familiarity of the family members. When a family member delivers an opinion, the rest may associate that with how they know him in the past, rather than how he commits to it in the future. The atmosphere of the group is then surrounded by clouds of doubt, discouragement, and insecurity, which no longer makes the group suited to journey together.

Taken our case into consideration, a number of roles come into the picture. We had Father-Son relationship. Husband-Wife, Parents-Children, Siblings-Siblings, Director-Director, as President, as Vice Presidents, as Experts, and Employer-Employee are also some of those.

During my first year in the company, it was frequent when my parents' husband-wife and other family-related arguments extended during our meetings and resulted to unfinished, disrupted and postponed meetings for about a week. There were also times when the members being accustomed to their respective family roles, then unable to find any reason to convince the others of their ideas. They got used to being the more authoritative figures in the family and all of a sudden, they were required, by reasons of the corporate environment, to persuade their co-directors whom, prior to this, they assumed to have complete authority over. And when it was time to put a motion into a vote, whatever you vote for could be possible subjects for misinterpretation, getting you accused of siding towards the more favored members of the family or worse, when you voted against one's idea, it could be believed to be because you wanted personal revenge for something that happened in the past. In turn, those whose ideas were not favored felt they were betrayed and despite it becoming the collective decision of the board, they would hardly ever feel they owned it or were part of it. These situations almost always led to the cycle of mistrust and bitterness which had been shuttering the very foundation of the family business.

With all those challenges, we have learned very important lessons: that to attain harmony in a family business requires us to be adaptive ourselves to the varying hats we wear and to forgo of that ego that we have been very accustomed of since we were growing up. It is necessary to faithfully and without prejudice play the role we are tasked at that moment, may it be a VP to a VP, and not allow the Parent-Son or an Elder-Younger Sibling relationship to create biases. That doesn't mean, however, that disrespect is freely let out. Of course, not! All the more in a corporate setup, professionalism should always be observed untainted with personal feelings.

What then is the most effective decision making method we have adopted up to now that allows us to continue operating the business? We are trying to achieve what Napoleon Hill describes as the becoming of a unified single mind; the Mastermind. When making decisions, everybody has to be in a unanimous decision agreeing towards the same goal. If one is not convinced, we put the issue into a park, however, putting the burden of its approval to the disapproving person. It is the responsibility of the individual person to think collectively achieving the unified vision and let this Mastermind tap into the individual conscience of the family members. This method has in fact drastically decreased the number of disagreements we have.

The ability of the family to come up with sound decisions defines whether or not them journeying together is a worthwhile endeavor. If, on the contrary, issues within the business escalate to personal ones destroying the family itself, it is best that the family members journey alone and preserve their relationships.

As the business becomes bigger and more complex, all the more the family has to realize that sharing the responsibility and degree of control over the various critical decision making processes is the top most priority. A single person cannot alone create more things than he is bound by the limits of his energy, time, and resources. But, together with his family, working in synergy makes the whole family business easier and worthwhile.

Sunday, January 27, 2013

From the Perspective of a 3rd Generation Businessman

Those Were The Times

A friend of mine once stereotyped my family as one of the typical Chinese families he came to know: one that is very thrifty and owns a hardware business; and he is right. My grandfather was an immigrant from Fujian, China. He came to the Philippines in the hope of finding a greener pasture. He had been in many places in the country, married his second wife in Iloilo and finally migrated down here in the beautiful innocent southern island of the Philippines, Mindanao.

One of those businesses he started was a Wholesale and Retail Business; which up to now is one of the bread and butter of our family. This business paved way to other businesses involving Distribution, Production, Manufacturing, and Real Estate Development which had been managed by six of his children, my dad was third after his two twin elder sisters; but in the point of view of the traditional Chinese culture, he is the eldest, being the first-born male.

Back when I was in college, those in the 2nd generation (that of my dad) started giving us series of lectures on how we can come in to the business. At that time, the family business had started professionalizing, hiring consultants here and there, automating business processes, and the fun part, doing team buildings from time to time. Judging on how early they tried conditioning us (the 3rd generation) on the possibility of coming into the family business, I noticed the invitation wasn't a sure hit. To avoid problems such as free rides and future unbalanced voting power, they structured it to make us start from the bottom and on our way to higher positions. We were repetitively told of an old saying, "The first generation builds the business, the second makes it a success, and the third spends it”, which is what the family had been trying to avoid.

A Mountain of Opportunities

It is obvious to consider that the first generation (my grandparents) had experienced the most financial difficulties. My dad and his siblings would have seen all the struggles the family had encountered and for every sweat my grandfather shed was equivalent to a set of commitments he and his siblings established which led them expanding the business.

On our case, however, what we observed were those days when the businesses were growing. Although my parents were very thrifty on us, like back then, our allowance per day was just equal to our grade level (1 peso = Grade 1), those times were definitely a lot better than when we weren't still born. That then gave us a different level of experience and expectation as compared to our parents'.

I went to Philippine Science High School - Southern Mindanao Campus, which literally cost just 60.00 a month for the dormitory, even if it was considered a premiere high school in the country. Afterwhich I went to De La Salle University - Manila for my college earning a bachelor degree in Computer Science and graduated Cum Laude. Those credentials gave me all the necessary stuff for me to land a high paying job and in fact I was on that route after graduating.

An opportunity to work in Singapore was only a few months away before my dad called me up and had me consider working for the business. I was faced with crossroads. It was inevitable that sooner or later, I would have to finally come into the business and help it grow, but I didn't expect it to be that soon. I had all sorts of dreams, including being a nomadic executive visiting different regional offices every week. That would have earned me enough experience to be credible enough to help in growing the family business; and of course five to eight years of "complete freedom".

Deciding Between Two Apples

The worst kind of decision is when it is between two good options; they were both equally appealing and tasty. Had it been just me working in Manila, I would have immediately grabbed the latter; or not, I haven't really thought about it.

It was during this time when I couldn't thank a Singaporean friend more for helping me sort this out. He told me that I actually knew what I wanted deep down, I just had to put it into writing and be very honest during the whole process; and so I drew my thought in a quadrant. On top was the opportunity to work and on the bottom was to go into business. On the left side were the specific pros, and on the right were the cons. The pros of the first option were not necessarily the cons of the second, as I was choosing between two seemingly equally great options.


 Pros
 Cons
Overseas Employment
  • Salary
  • Official Title of a Jetsetter
  • Complete Freedom
  • IT Learning
  • Time with Colleagues
  • A Life of a Working Bachelor

  • Different Value System
  • Time is not Mine
  • On Call

Family Business 
  • Shares - Dividends
  • Help the Business
  • Increased Savings (Business pays for expenses)
  • 100% Family Time
  • I am my Own Boss (After My Dad)

  • Initial Salary (until who knows when)
  • Remote Provincial Setting



It took me the whole night to write them down, but the ones in the quadrant weren't enough. Those I wrote weren't what troubled me most. It was the list of future opportunity costs which may or may not happen at all. Things such as the rate of salary increase, the applicability of what I learnt in Singapore to the business eight years from then, the scope and complexity of work in the business, and the ego that comes with the two options.

Choosing the first option meant the family business had to wait for eight years til I get to set my eyes on it. Choosing the second, on the other hand, meant the first would be lost forever. At that time, I had more than a week to decide until time made it easier for me to choose.

My dad called up again and told me it was official: that the second generation decided they considered specializing on and managing of the different businesses independently. It meant the wholesale and retail business my grandfather started, the raw material processing, and one of the production businesses would solely be managed by my parents. Considering that my dad somewhat had these businesses primarily under his care anyways, it wouldn't be much of a problem. However, what had him worrying was the unfinished automation of the business processes, which after several turnovers still encountered major system bugs and slowdowns. That was why he wanted me badly. On the other hand, straight from training for the deployment, I had no idea how to fix what I was supposed to, and feared I'd put more damage than solution to the already problematic system.

But that pretty much solved the case. I chose the latter because I knew it was the time when the business could sink or swim. Emotionally, my dad was experiencing difficulties and moving away could put additional stress to the family. If I would come in eight years after, I guess the amount of contribution I would be giving will be small compared to if I'd join the business then; or worse, there's no business I could even join to; but I guess this was very unlikely.

Looking Through A Different Pair of Eyes

It was funny how my Master's Thesis adviser remarked that joining the family business would put my university credentials to waste. He envisioned me to be one of those COOs (Child of Owners) acting just as cashiers round a clock to a typical Chinese-managed shop. That remark honestly got me to worry a bit, but I  assured myself, had I been presented with just that option, the deployment would have been a sure choice.

Rather, I was directly assigned to do what it would take to fix the IT/Development department. To be honest, apart from the system slowdowns, it was doing okay, but security measures were very lax, diagrams, policies, and the infrastructure were nowhere to be found. And so I did what I was expected to do: I fixed it. The training I had did an amazing job allowing me to use some of the best practices but as more practical problems arose, we needed consultants.

It was not just the IT/Development department that was in trouble; so were all the other departments: HR, Finance, and even Operation. They were the kinds of problems that had been existing for years but still haven't been solved because although they were problems, they weren't urgent. The business proceeded as if carrying with it a ticking time-bomb, you never know when it is going to blast, or if it will ever do.

Problems are inevitable in businesses. For every problem that is solved, more difficult problems will spring out. It was the consistent push for correcting and preventing problems that preoccupied me. On top of those, I was faced with a more difficult kind of problem, that of managing people. Of course, I was already the boss. At 20 years old I sat both on an executive position and on the board, due to the fact that I was simply a COO (Child of Owner). I knew I was credible enough due to the credentials I had earned through the years but the people I was managing couldn't care less. These were the people who some of them I grew up with. They knew me when I was a kid, naive and playful, but all of a sudden they were now implicitly required to add a salutation, "Sir" and greeting me during the morning was something they felt they were obliged to do.

It was a tag of war in terms of gaining respect. It was awkwardness at its finest. Calling resisting employees who were more than ten years older than me by their first name, which is in our culture, a salutation of "manong, manang, kuya, ate" are prerequisites when speaking to older people, was hard to do. Respect is something to be earned and is not demanded. I still maintained those salutations to my employees who have earned my respect and have understood the whole process. However, for them to impose their authority over me, and take the situation manipulatively, I had to stand my ground and allow them to experience my firmness. I did not demand respect but I also did not allow their length of tenure as well as their age to make myself hesitant for any necessary measures I needed to impose.

Sitting in a meeting together with my parents was another difficulty. Outside of work, they were my parents. However, during work, I wore different hats. On one scenario, my dad was my boss because he was the president, while I'm a vice president of a department. However, on this same scenario, I was on equal footing with my mom, as she also was just a vice president. On another scenario, as board of directors, we had equal rights of opinions and varying votes depending on the number of shares. These roles, regrettably, initially often led to week-long quarrels and silent treatments. We were not used to varying roles and the line dividing the personal and the professional interests were very thin. There was also one time when an agent during his visit in the office was so shocked I was passionately rebutting my dad for an idea, and even had my voice a bit raised uncontrollably. He might have wondered how my dad simply allowed his son to disrespectfully talk back to him just like that.

Taking Ownership

It is worth noting that our family business case, although my grandfather was pure Chinese, deviates a lot from what others stereotype us as such. My parents were crazy in allowing me to have a share of their pie. I wondered if they thought about this when they considered giving me shares and voting rights. As early as my age, I have been able to constantly immerse myself in discussions of ideas and business strategies. I have grown more emotionally mature and open to them, and at the same time maintain that level of respect I have to them as their son outside of work.

Today, as I evaluate the quadrant I drew, many of the pros at the bottom outweigh those on top by a number of folds. I realized that starting small is not defeating the demands of the ego. Doing business takes a lot of focus, patience, and sacrifices. I, for one, don't get to party as often as if I had chosen the first option. Weekdays and Weekends are no different, they are all work days; just that vacations and occasional absences can be done anytime I prefer; but funny how sometimes I would be the one protesting if the family decides for a vacation during when I have a lot of things to finish.

Starting young also got me the title, "Youngest Businessman" in our local chamber of commerce. When already in the business, it is inevitable that I also get to hang with like-minded people, those also active in the business my age and a whole lot older than me as well as those already successful ones from different parts of the country.

A couple of months ago, I started a humble Software Development Company and co-formed together with other IT entrepreneurs in the region our local ICT council. It is not yet close to success but that is what the three-generation paradox is all about.

Starting a few endeavors is the liking of a first-generation businessman. Improving, Sustaining, and Expanding them are what the second-generation businessmen do. Enjoying the fruit (but not killing the goose) is what my typical generation should do. I believe I have broken the three-generation curse. In the hope of mastering it, the 3rd generation businessman has entered the territory of the other two generations.